Hydroponics vs Soil: Which is Better for Indoor Plants

Many people want to grow their indoor gardens but don't know where to start. They're scared about what kind of soil product to use since so many options vary widely in cost, effort, and quality.

A soil-based indoor garden is usually the first step for new gardeners who are starting. Because soil seems the most natural way for plants to grow, it seems quite natural for plants to grow in soil.

It is, of course, possible that people would take to hydroponics as an alternative to growing plants in the soil as their gardens grow and require more time and effort. This is exactly why people are looking for alternatives such as hydroponics.

Hydroponics and soil are both popular gardening methods, but they are different. Let's find out the main difference between hydroponics and soil so you can decide which one is best for your needs.

Hydroponics: What Does It Mean?

Growing plants without soil in a hydroponic garden are called hydroponic gardening. Roots grow in nutrient solutions rather than soil, in the form of mineral nutrient solutions in a solvent like water.

"Hydroponics" is a term that originates in Latin and means "working water." Hydroponic systems come in various types. A nutrient film system and an ebb-and-flow system are two examples.

Hydroponics plants grow in nutrient solutions. Vitamins and minerals are infused into this liquid to feed the roots. An example of calcium is calcium carbonate, which contains calcium, phosphorus, and nitrogen. To soil, it is similar to fertilizer. 

The nutrients you need will depend on the crop you're growing. A person can either purchase nutrient solutions that are chemically based or make their DIY nutrient solutions.

The Difference Between Growing in Water and Soil

what is best for indoor plants Hydroponics vs Soil

It is possible to manipulate the environment to increase growth rate and yield by growing in water instead of soil with careful monitoring.

Hydroponics has many benefits, including the fact that it uses less water to grow food. Since hydroponics requires less water to grow plants, it is becoming increasingly popular as a growing method instead of soil.

 When water isn't available, it's an excellent choice. A hydroponic garden does not require soil to be good, so you don't need to consider poor soil for your garden. 

Hydroponics is also advantageous in harsh climates and unpredictable weather since it can be grown without soil. Hydroponically growing outdoors year-round may be possible if you live in a moderate climate. 

A hydroponic greenhouse hydroponic system can be set up indoors if you live in a climate with four seasons. It will therefore be possible for you to enjoy yields for a long period.

Soil Cultivation: What Does It Mean?

Soil is the most common medium in which plants are cultivated. In other words, normal soil is the media for the plants in those conditions. Several other subcategories of soil cultivations can also be classified under soil cultivations. 

Various cultivation methods are available, including field and potted cultivations. Land preparation and other pre-cultivation practices prepare agricultural lands for field cultivation. 

Other management practices can be simplified by converting the land into cultivation beds.

It is believed that ancient farmers did not add extra fertilizer to their soils to cultivate their crops.

 As an alternative, they rotated the land regularly rather than constantly changing it. Despite this, it is evident that because there are not enough agricultural lands, there is not enough rotation of land to make things work. 

Essentially, they are unable to wait until the land has been rehabilitated before they can start using it. Consequently, farmers add chemical fertilizers to their fields to obtain more rapid reactions. 

As a result, the soil grows fertile, allowing the plants to absorb its nutrients. It's important to use the right soil for the right plant.

A hydroponic plant is grown without soil using any method that can be described. A plant might be grown in water or another germ-free medium, such as clay LECA balls, but not in actual soil; however, in some cases, the plant may grow in water.


Read More

Plant Food vs Fertilizer

The main advantage of LECA over the soil is that it is much less messy and has a natural neutral pH, which makes it a wonderful substrate for indoor plants. You can keep your indoor plants happy by providing them with the right mix of food, moisture, and air as they grow through LECA clay.

What is the Difference Between Hydroponics and Soil?

It is self-explanatory once you learn what hydroponics is and understand how it differs from the soil. However, we will give you a quick overview of the topic. 

Plants rely on the soil for several reasons, such as stabilizing themselves, developing roots, and absorbing nutrients and water from the soil to grow.


Hydroponics is an environment in which plants grow without soil. Still, they are continuously supplied with nutrients and water by nutrient-rich solutions, which are kept in a nutrient-rich solution very close to their roots.


There are several advantages to hydroponics, such as nutrient and water availability, but with hydroponics, plants do not have a medium that stabilizes the plants.


The growing process of plants is made easier by using a special type of footing specifically designed to allow the plants to grow and stabilize.

Hydroponics vs. Soil Cost- Which is Cheaper?

Hydroponics vs Soil Which is cheaper

It depends on a few factors whether to use hydroponics or soil. Most of the time, hydroponics will tend to be a bit costlier overall. On the other hand, this is only a first impression. One of the most important factors is the size of your garden.


You will likely be able to get a better deal on hydroponic gardening if you have a larger hydroponic garden. The soil will be cheaper than hydroponics for smaller gardens.

Setup costs at the beginning.

When you set up the hydroponics equipment and system, there are some initial setup costs, but they are refundable after some time. There will also be a cost if you use LED grow lights. Leca Balls also needed for hydroponics indoor gardening. you find best quality leca balls at planterhoma in cheap price.

The cost of gardening with soil may be one of the expenses that you need to consider. It will be necessary for you to build out an area for your garden in advance.

There is a possibility that soil will have to be brought in for the project. If you want to keep animals out of your garden, you may need to invest in a system to keep them away.

Continual expenses Hydroponics vs Soil

If you decide to grow with hydroponics, you must remember that ongoing costs will be involved. Your choice of growing medium will determine how long it takes for your seeds to sprout.


It is also important to remember that a nutrient solution will be needed to feed the plants, which will be an additional expense. Electricity costs are another cost involved in hydroponically grown plants.


Adding store-bought compost, organic fertilizer, worm castings, and mulch to your soil before planting will add additional expense to soil gardening.


Soil gardens will be more expensive because of all of these factors. There is another way to save money if you have your compost pile and you possess mulch from your garden in the form of leaves.

Do indoor plants benefit from self-watering pots?

Your houseplants will remain healthy if you use self-watering planters. It is not only important to avoid overwatering your houseplants, but they can also help to prevent drying out on your plants.


There are many benefits to owning a self-watering planter.


  • Reduce the risk of disease.
  • Reduces water consumption.
  • Create a growing flexible space.
  • Moisture the roots.
  • Consistently supply water.
  • Soil preserves nutrients.


Hydroponic vs Soil Pros and Cons

Hydroponics has many benefits, although some may prefer more conventional growing methods. A hydroponic garden is a great alternative to growing a garden in soil for the following reasons.


Dimensions of the space needed.

Whether you grow in the ground or a garden bed, soil gardening takes up a lot of space in your yard. Furthermore, hydroponics uses less space than pots and planters to produce the same yield.


Hydroponics allows you to grow more food in a smaller area with less work. For a plant to obtain its nutrients, there is no need to interact with soil, so there is no need for soil.


An alternative solution is to give the plant directly the solution created for it. In this way, long roots are not required as in soil.


Because plants do not require soil to receive nutrients, you won't need as much space to house them as you would if they were in the soil.


Plants can grow successfully so long as you have enough mineral solution for the plants and enough for the mineral solution.

Utilization of water.

There are times when there is no water available. Additionally, it is a natural resource that can be expensive when one grows many plants, as it is a limited resource.


Growing hydroponically instead of in soil may be a better choice. A hydroponic system uses less water to grow more. The environment will benefit from this as less water will be used, and your water bill will be less expensive. Self-watering planter are best choice for hydroponics as they have a wick to water the plant.


As opposed to soil gardens, hydroponic gardens utilize much less water and can conserve up to ten times more water. In other words, it prevents the plant from getting too much water.


Because the nutrients remain in the container for longer, this is due to the reservoir system.

Once the plant receives enough nutrients, the remaining nutrients are stored there until the time comes for them to be used again by the plant.  


Moreover, since the reservoir is not exposed to sunlight, it does not evaporate as it is not exposed to air. You must be careful not to over-water or under-water your plants when gardening soil.

Hydroponic vs Soil growth Rate

Plants grow faster when they are hydroponically grown. Their fast growth makes it easy to see if anything is wrong right away and if it's affecting their growth.


In addition to this, making adjustments will have a quicker result, too, so that you can see whether or not something is working and what is not.

Hydroponics Versus Soil Comparison.

We'll compare hydroponics and soil based on several characteristics now that you're familiar with their differences. Discover which indoor garden is best for you by comparing yield, space requirements, nutrients, and water needs.

Do plants grow faster in water or soil?

Hydroponic plants are healthier and stronger than those that grow in the soil if you compare their health. Aside from this, hydroponics also causes a higher yield, as the plants grown in hydroponics contain more vitamins and nutrients than those grown in soil, thus providing a healthier yield.


In addition, hydroponically grown plants are less susceptible to pests and diseases because they are healthier than soil-grown plants.

A plant's efficiency.

There is no comparison between soil and hydroponics when it comes to efficiency. Due to hydroponics' direct supply of nutrients, plants grow more rapidly since they receive them directly.


In terms of nutrients, plants growing in soil require a much greater amount of nutrients than roots growing in this setup as compared to plants growing in soil. Soil-grown plants, however, grow more slowly because they lack the advantages of hydroponically grown plants.

Water management.

The results of hydroponics are evident; plants grown in soil are not as healthy as those grown in hydroponics. Hydroponics and soil gardening can also be compared based on the water required.


Compared to hydroponically grown plants, soil-grown plants require much more water. Hydroponics does not evaporate water like soil, so the water circulates continuously.

Cost Hydroponics vs. Soil.

Continuing our comparison of hydroponics vs. soil, the comparison would be incomplete until we compare their costs.


Generally speaking, hydroponics can be regarded as a more expensive affair when compared to soil-based systems. Hydroponic systems are available in various sizes and types but are more expensive.


Maintaining a hydroponic system is also expensive because the nutrients and water necessary to keep the system working require constant circulation, both of which are expensive to maintain.


In contrast, if you look at a hydroponic system in comparison to a soil-based system, it is generally cheaper than a hydroponic system. Therefore, this is less of an investment if you grow an indoor garden with soil.

Final Words

In general, hydroponic growing methods are safer, more nutrient-rich, and produce healthier indoor plants in less time when compared to soil systems. You can check different self watering planters at planterhoma for hydroponic indoor garden


However, the benefits of hydroponics do not come easy or cheap, as many hydroponic setups require a large initial investment in equipment and ongoing maintenance.


Is it better to grow in soil or hydroponics?

Growing hydroponic plants can increase production by 30 percent and accelerate growth. The advantages of hydroponics over soil are more obvious.

Is hydroponic cheaper than soil?

The cost of hydroponics varies depending on a few factors. In general, hydroponics is more expensive than soil-based farming.

Is hydroponics more water efficient than soil?

Compared to the soil, hydroponics has far greater efficiency because The plants receive their nutrients directly in hydroponics.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.